• Subscribe
    • Franklin Living Magazine
    • Services
      • About Us
      • Subscribe
      • Policies
      • Terms of use
      • Submit a news tip
      • Submit a photo
      • Birth announcement
      • Birthday announcement
      • Engagement announcement
      • Wedding announcement
      • Submit a Classified Ad
      • Letter to the Editor
    • Classifieds
    • E-editions
    • Public Notices
      • Public Notices
      • Alabama Public Notices
    • Subscribe
    • Franklin Living Magazine
    • Services
      • About Us
      • Subscribe
      • Policies
      • Terms of use
      • Submit a news tip
      • Submit a photo
      • Birth announcement
      • Birthday announcement
      • Engagement announcement
      • Wedding announcement
      • Submit a Classified Ad
      • Letter to the Editor
    • Classifieds
    • E-editions
    • Public Notices
      • Public Notices
      • Alabama Public Notices

Franklin County Times
  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Opinion
  • Lifestyles
  • Obituaries
  • Records
  • Subscribe
  • Services
  • About Us
  • Subscribe
  • Policies
  • Terms of use
  • Submit a news tip
  • Submit a photo
  • Birth Announcement
  • Birthday announcement
  • Engagement announcement
  • Wedding announcement
  • Submit a Classified Ad
  • Letters to the Editor
  • Classifieds
  • Public Notices
    Franklin County Times
      • Site logo
      • Home
      • News
        • Russellville
        • Red Bay
        • Phil Campbell
        • Franklin County
        • Photo Galleries
        • Sponsored Content
      • Sports
        • Belgreen Bulldogs
        • Phil Campbell Bobcats
        • Red Bay Tigers
        • Russellville Golden Tigers
        • Tharptown Wildcats
        • Vina Red Devils
        • College Sports
        • Sports Columnists
      • Opinion
        • Letters to the Editor
        • Columnists
        • Editorials
      • Lifestyles
        • Birthdays
        • Births
        • Couples
        • Food
        • Features
      • Obituaries
      • Records
        • Sheriff’s Report
        • Marriages
        • Land Transactions
        • Police Reports
      • Special Sections
      • Site logo
      • Home
      • News
        • Russellville
        • Red Bay
        • Phil Campbell
        • Franklin County
        • Photo Galleries
        • Sponsored Content
      • Sports
        • Belgreen Bulldogs
        • Phil Campbell Bobcats
        • Red Bay Tigers
        • Russellville Golden Tigers
        • Tharptown Wildcats
        • Vina Red Devils
        • College Sports
        • Sports Columnists
      • Opinion
        • Letters to the Editor
        • Columnists
        • Editorials
      • Lifestyles
        • Birthdays
        • Births
        • Couples
        • Food
        • Features
      • Obituaries
      • Records
        • Sheriff’s Report
        • Marriages
        • Land Transactions
        • Police Reports
      • Special Sections
    Bart Moss, Opinion
     By  Staff Reports Published 
    4:17 pm Tuesday, April 1, 2014

    Should college athletes be paid?

    Bart Moss

    Columnist

    There is a drama unfolding in college athletics, but isn’t there always? But unlike other sports dramas, this drama could affect the game many of us in the state of Alabama have grown to love.

    The argument that college athletes should be paid is not new. What is new is the steam being gained by some lawsuits and political activities.

    Two major events are unfolding on this issue. First, former UCLA basketball player Ed O’Bannon’s lawsuit to allow players to receive a portion of their jersey sales has reached federal court. O’Bannon also believes players should be able to sell their likeness and make money off of autographs. Second, Northwestern football players have convinced a regional office of the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) that college athletes are employees and should be able to form a union.

    The debate was also the subject of a segment on Meet the Press last Sunday. The participants were Mark Emmert (president of the NCAA), Reggie Love (former Duke basketball player and former personal aide to President Obama) and Arne Duncan (President Obama’s secretary of education).

    Jeffery Kessler, a lawyer representing some athletes, said that “coaches are getting paid $5 million, schools are generating hundreds of millions, sponsors are cashing in, and administrators are cashing in. The only group that is not receiving any benefit are these athletes, most of who will not graduate and most of who will never be a professional athlete.”

    Arne Duncan added, “guys I played with on the south side of Chicago made a lot of money for the universities, never got their degree, came back home with nothing to show for it. Something is fundamentally unfair about that.”

    Let’s be honest here. What they are talking about is big-time college football and big-time men’s basketball (i.e. Auburn, Alabama, Florida, Kentucky, etc). They are not talking about UNA, Samford, and junior colleges. They are not talking about women’s basketball, softball, golf or track.

    First, to suggest college athletes are not “receiving any benefit” or are being treated “unfair” is preposterous and insulting to any thinking person’s intelligence.

    These student-athletes are getting the opportunity to get an education, which is invaluable. The key word is opportunity. Some take advantage of the opportunity, others do not. There is absolutely no reason why a college athlete shouldn’t graduate. They get their tuition, housing, books and meals as part of their scholarship (approximately $23,000 per year at Auburn and Alabama). They have access to the best tutors, educational resources, first priority on classes and access to a network of boosters that no amount of money can buy that “regular” students don’t have access to.

    The problem is that just like many high school athletes and their parents think they are going to get a major college scholarship to play sports, most players who get major college scholarships think they are going to go pro. And the likelihood of it happening on either level is very small.

    Second, the whole premise in this debate is whether or not you view this as an employer/employee relationship or a privilege and opportunity. I view it as the latter. I view it as an opportunity that just about every kid dreams of. I view it as an opportunity to make contacts with coaches, administrators, and boosters that can propel a student to a great career upon graduation.

    Third, when a student-athlete accepts a scholarship, they are making a choice. They are choosing to use the extra time they would have to study or work a part-time job to fulfill the duties of their scholarship. Yes, the fact that the NCAA will not allow scholarship athletes to work a part-time job doesn’t seem fair – on the surface. If the NCAA allowed part-time employment, you can only imagine the great part-time jobs some players would get.

    Fourth, if players are allowed to profit off of jersey sales, autographs or using their image to advertise, what is going to stop schools with deep-pocketed boosters from promising that if you come to [pick your school] we will make sure you get top-dollar for your autograph and someone will buy a lot of your jerseys? Also, what does it do to a college team’s chemistry when the star quarterback and running back are making more than the linemen blocking for them?

    Fifth, if you pay the big-time football and basketball players, you are going to have Title IX lawsuits filed all over the country in a matter of minutes. If you pay football and basketball players, you must pay members of the baseball, softball, track, golf, tennis, swimming and diving, gymnastics, equestrian, and whatever other sports teams are offered.

    Finally, even if student-athletes are given a stipend, it’s not going to solve anything. You are still going to have the “hundred-dollar handshakes” and some of the stipend money will be used to purchase things/services that may embarrass the taxpayer or donor base. If there is a way to provide a small cost-of-attendance stipend and make sure it is used for critical living expenses, then I’m all for it (for all student-athletes). Maybe there could be a reimbursement process put in place where receipts would be required to prevent abuse. I don’t know the answer.

    So, in my opinion, leave things the way they are. It’s not perfect, but what is? It may not be fair, but neither is life.

    If a high school player is good enough to earn a scholarship to pay for their education then I’m proud for them. But they should get no other benefits than the typical student. The truth is, the vast majority of student-athletes prioritize their time and work hard to earn a degree, many with honors, and are successful athletes. They go on to very productive and successful careers.

    Unfortunately, some do not prioritize their time or work hard on their education. They go to school to play sports and that’s it. They think they are going pro. They think studying can wait. They think someone will take care of them and pass them anyway just because they are a ballplayer. These are the people making the noise. They have got to the end of their eligibility and have nothing to show for it because they have felt entitled their entire life. It’s not their fault. It’s the adults around them that made them that way, but that’s a story for later.

    Also on Franklin County Times
    PHOTO GALLERY: Jam at Sloss Lake
    Franklin County, Galleries, Lifestyles
    PHOTO GALLERY: Jam at Sloss Lake
    Griffin Traylor 
    July 9, 2025
    Auditor says city’s financial health is very good
    Main, News, Russellville, ...
    Auditor says city’s financial health is very good
    María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
    July 9, 2025
    RUSSELLVILLE -- The city has received what its auditor called a “clean opinion” on its fiscal year 2024 audit, meaning no significant deficiencies or ...
    {"epopulate_editorials_prism":"epopulate_editorials_prism"}
    Place of Grace opens recovery home in Franklin County
    Franklin County, Main, News, ...
    Place of Grace opens recovery home in Franklin County
    María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
    July 9, 2025
    The Place of Grace has opened a new recovery home in Franklin County, offering women a structured, faith-based environment to continue their journey a...
    {"epopulate_editorials_prism":"epopulate_editorials_prism"}
    Hamilton: Title II funding freeze is a concern
    Main, News, Russellville, ...
    Hamilton: Title II funding freeze is a concern
    Alyssa Sutherland For the FCT 
    July 9, 2025
    R U S S E L L V I L L E – Franklin County Superintendent Greg Hamilton is concerned about the status of more than $6 billion in federal education gran...
    {"epopulate_editorials_prism":"epopulate_editorials_prism"}
    Fire Department receives new $2.2M platform truck
    Main, News, Russellville, ...
    Fire Department receives new $2.2M platform truck
    María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
    July 9, 2025
    RUSSELLVILLE Firefighters and city officials showed off the Fire Department’s new $2.2 million 100-foot platform fire truck in a safety demonstration ...
    {"epopulate_editorials_prism":"epopulate_editorials_prism"}
    Palmer certified for fourth term on Russellville Council
    News, Russellville, Z - News Main
    Palmer certified for fourth term on Russellville Council
    María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
    July 9, 2025
    RUSSELLVILLE – The city council approved a certificate of election stating Councilman David Palmer was the only candidate to qualify for Council Distr...
    {"epopulate_editorials_prism":"epopulate_editorials_prism"}
    Summer camps nurture faith, friendship and growth
    Columnists, Opinion
    HERE AND NOW
    Summer camps nurture faith, friendship and growth
    July 9, 2025
    Susie Hovater Malone Columnist During the summer many Franklin County youths enjoy attending summer camps, where they engage in hiking, swimming, spor...
    {"epopulate_editorials_prism":"epopulate_editorials_prism"}
    The prosperity we enjoy depends on Sea Lanes of Communication
    Columnists, Opinion
    The prosperity we enjoy depends on Sea Lanes of Communication
    July 9, 2025
    The Pax Americana, the period since World War II when there have been no major world wars, has led to the greatest period of freedom the world has eve...
    {"epopulate_editorials_prism":"epopulate_editorials_prism"}

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    ❮ ❯
    Latest Local News
    PHOTO GALLERY: Jam at Sloss Lake
    PHOTO GALLERY: Jam at Sloss Lake
    July 9, 2025
    Auditor says city’s financial health is very good
    Auditor says city’s financial health is very good
    RUSSELLVILLE -- The city has received what its auditor called a “clean opinion” on its fiscal year 2024 audit, meaning no significant deficiencies or ...
    July 9, 2025
    Place of Grace opens recovery home in Franklin County
    Place of Grace opens recovery home in Franklin County
    The Place of Grace has opened a new recovery home in Franklin County, offering women a structured, faith-based environment to continue their journey a...
    July 9, 2025
    Hamilton: Title II funding freeze is a concern
    Hamilton: Title II funding freeze is a concern
    R U S S E L L V I L L E – Franklin County Superintendent Greg Hamilton is concerned about the status of more than $6 billion in federal education gran...
    July 9, 2025
    Fire Department receives new $2.2M platform truck
    Fire Department receives new $2.2M platform truck
    RUSSELLVILLE Firefighters and city officials showed off the Fire Department’s new $2.2 million 100-foot platform fire truck in a safety demonstration ...
    July 9, 2025

    More Local News

    Latest Stories
    Municipal elections: Let your voice be heard on Aug. 26
    Qualifying for municipal races across the state, including Franklin County, closed on June 24 leaving several contested races leading up to the Aug. 2...
    July 9, 2025
    TVA surcharge to raise August bills for customers
    RUSSELLVILLE Electricity customers should expect higher bills in August as TVA passes along a surcharge driven by high summer demand and a recent outa...
    July 9, 2025
    Hutcheson participates in CCHS program
    Hutcheson participates in CCHS program
    PHIL CAMPBELL — Rising Phil Campbell High School senior Hudson Hutcheson spent most of his summer at the University of Alabama. An aspiring dentist, h...
    July 9, 2025
    Being struck by lightning was ‘shocking experience’
    Being struck by lightning was ‘shocking experience’
    RUSSELLVILLE — Lisa Henderson was lying on her bed, scrolling through social media sites on her phone and enjoying a cozy, rainy Sunday afternoon with...
    July 9, 2025
    Jeffreys named new head football coach at Red Bay
    Jeffreys named new head football coach at Red Bay
    RED BAY -- Tyler Jeffreys has been named the new head coach at Red Bay High School. Jeffreys is stepping in to replace Heath Childers, who recently re...
    July 9, 2025
    Latest Sports
    Jeffreys named new head football coach at Red Bay
    Jeffreys named new head football coach at Red Bay
    RED BAY -- Tyler Jeffreys has been named the new head coach at Red Bay High School. Jeffreys is stepping in to replace Heath Childers, who recently re...
    July 9, 2025
    Hamilton to play baseball at Blue Mountain College
    Hamilton to play baseball at Blue Mountain College
    RED BAY -- Red Bay High School’s Reed Hamilton has officially signed a scholarship to continue his education and baseball career at Blue Mountain Coll...
    July 9, 2025
    Allison tapped to lead Lady Bobcats softball
    Allison tapped to lead Lady Bobcats softball
    PHIL CAMPBELL -- A familiar face will be leading the Phil Campbell High School Lady Bobcats softball program next season. Darby Allison, a 2007 gradua...
    July 2, 2025
    6 local students accepted into FAME program
    6 local students accepted into FAME program
    Northwest Shoals Community College (NWSCC) has signed 6 Franklin County students to its 2025–26 Federation for Advanced Manufacturing Education (FAME)...
    July 2, 2025
    Junior golfers hone skills through summer program
    Junior golfers hone skills through summer program
    RUSSELLVILLE -- A young generation of golfers teed off this summer at Twin Pines Country Club, thanks to a local effort to create opportunities for ch...
    July 2, 2025

    More Sports Stories

    x

    Sections

    • Home
    • News
    • Sports
    • Opinion
    • Lifestyles
    • Obits
    • Special Sections
    • Sponsored Content
      • Home
      • News
      • Sports
      • Opinion
      • Lifestyles
      • Obits
      • Special Sections
      • Sponsored Content

    Services

    • About Us
    • Subscribe
    • Advertise With Us
    • Policies
    • Terms of use
    • Submit a news tip
    • Submit a photo
    • Birth announcement
    • Birthday announcement
    • Engagement announcement
    • Wedding announcement
    • Submit a Classified Ad
    • Letter to the Editor
    • Sign Up For Our Free Newsletter
      • About Us
      • Subscribe
      • Advertise With Us
      • Policies
      • Terms of use
      • Submit a news tip
      • Submit a photo
      • Birth announcement
      • Birthday announcement
      • Engagement announcement
      • Wedding announcement
      • Submit a Classified Ad
      • Letter to the Editor
      • Sign Up For Our Free Newsletter

    Follow Us

    Copyright

    © , Franklin County Times