• Subscribe
    • Franklin Living Magazine
    • Services
      • About Us
      • Subscribe
      • Policies
      • Terms of use
      • Submit a news tip
      • Submit a photo
      • Birth announcement
      • Birthday announcement
      • Engagement announcement
      • Wedding announcement
      • Submit a Classified Ad
      • Letter to the Editor
    • Classifieds
    • E-editions
    • Public Notices
      • Public Notices
      • Alabama Public Notices
    • Subscribe
    • Franklin Living Magazine
    • Services
      • About Us
      • Subscribe
      • Policies
      • Terms of use
      • Submit a news tip
      • Submit a photo
      • Birth announcement
      • Birthday announcement
      • Engagement announcement
      • Wedding announcement
      • Submit a Classified Ad
      • Letter to the Editor
    • Classifieds
    • E-editions
    • Public Notices
      • Public Notices
      • Alabama Public Notices

Franklin County Times
  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Opinion
  • Lifestyles
  • Obituaries
  • Records
  • Subscribe
  • Services
  • About Us
  • Subscribe
  • Policies
  • Terms of use
  • Submit a news tip
  • Submit a photo
  • Birth Announcement
  • Birthday announcement
  • Engagement announcement
  • Wedding announcement
  • Submit a Classified Ad
  • Letters to the Editor
  • Classifieds
  • Public Notices
    Franklin County Times
      • Site logo
      • Home
      • News
        • Russellville
        • Red Bay
        • Phil Campbell
        • Franklin County
        • Photo Galleries
        • Sponsored Content
      • Sports
        • Belgreen Bulldogs
        • Phil Campbell Bobcats
        • Red Bay Tigers
        • Russellville Golden Tigers
        • Tharptown Wildcats
        • Vina Red Devils
        • College Sports
        • Sports Columnists
      • Opinion
        • Letters to the Editor
        • Columnists
        • Editorials
      • Lifestyles
        • Birthdays
        • Births
        • Couples
        • Food
        • Features
      • Obituaries
      • Records
        • Sheriff’s Report
        • Marriages
        • Land Transactions
        • Police Reports
      • Special Sections
      • Site logo
      • Home
      • News
        • Russellville
        • Red Bay
        • Phil Campbell
        • Franklin County
        • Photo Galleries
        • Sponsored Content
      • Sports
        • Belgreen Bulldogs
        • Phil Campbell Bobcats
        • Red Bay Tigers
        • Russellville Golden Tigers
        • Tharptown Wildcats
        • Vina Red Devils
        • College Sports
        • Sports Columnists
      • Opinion
        • Letters to the Editor
        • Columnists
        • Editorials
      • Lifestyles
        • Birthdays
        • Births
        • Couples
        • Food
        • Features
      • Obituaries
      • Records
        • Sheriff’s Report
        • Marriages
        • Land Transactions
        • Police Reports
      • Special Sections
    Archives
     By  Staff Reports Published 
    12:06 pm Wednesday, June 17, 2009

    Electrical outlets become focal point in Scott case

    By Staff
    Melissa Cason
    Franklin County Circuit Judge Terry Dempsey denied the defense's motion to dismiss the charges against Christie Michelle Scott, 32, of 180 Signore Drive in Russellville, Monday afternoon.
    The motion stems from missing power outlets taken from the house after the house fire that left six year-old Mason Scott dead in the early morning hours of Aug. 16, 2008.
    Defense Attorney Robert Tuten said the outlets were never evaluated by their experts for a second opinion, and the fact they were allowed to have the outlet checked 'impedes our defense' and Scott's civil rights.
    "The scene was clearly altered," Tuten said.
    Franklin County District Attorney Joey Rushing asked the court to hear more testimony before making a decision on this dismissal.
    "It's really early for this motion," Rushing said.
    Dempsey sided with the state by denying the motion, however, agreed to re-visit the motion in the future once more testimony has been heard.
    During Monday's testimony, the state continued to build the 'brick wall' of evidence against Scott by discrediting the defense's reason the smoke detector was not hanging on the wall.
    Firefighters Mickey Gentry and Jason Miller both testified that they entered the house in a search mode with a one and three-quarter inch fire hose, but no water was sprayed from the hose until they got the 'fire room'.
    "I did not turn the hose on until I got to the fire room," Gentry said. "I am not aware of anyone spraying water in the hallway."
    Gentry said once the hose was turned on they used the spray fog setting to get the fire out. The hose was never used in a straight stream in the house.
    "It only took a few minutes to get the fire out in the room," Gentry said.
    During the opening statements last week, Tuten offered the heavy water, as a reason the smoke alarm was not on the wall.
    Gentry testified that he did not hear the smoke detector go off, but also said he has been at fires before where no smoke detector sounded.
    The state contends the smoke detector was forcefully removed from the wall because Scott did not want Mason to hear it and get out of the house alive.
    Firefighter Jodi Hitt also testified about his search for Mason after the fire was extinguished.
    Hitt testified he went into different areas of the house looking in any place a small child might hide.
    "I was hoping for the best," Hitt said. "I was hoping maybe he got out."
    Hitt said his hopes were doused when he found Mason in his bedroom.
    "I informed the captain that I had located the boy," Hitt said. "They asked me for the condition of the body, and I said I didn't want to talk about it."
    Hitt said he stayed with Mason's body until the state fire marshal arrived to make sure the scene was not compromised.
    Hitt stayed on the scene to observe the investigation for educational purposes.
    Hitt was shown a series of pictures of different power outlets. He identified them all as power outlets with cut cords. Hitt was shown in one picture holding the outlet up by its cut cord.
    Hitt testified that on Thursday following the fire, he retrieved the outlets from the back of an investigator's car to allow the electrical engineer to assess them. Hitt admitted he did not know where the outlets are.
    The state admits the outlets are missing, prompting the motion for the dismissal of the charges.
    Rushing addressed the missing electrical outlets when Capt. Steve Thornton took the stand.
    Thornton was designated as the evidence custodian in the fire case, which means he was charged with securing evidence for prosecution.
    Thornton said the two outlets that were most important in this case are outlet three and outlet four.
    Thornton said he had outlet three in his possession the entire time, but it was mislabeled. He did not realize that he had outlet three until he started examining photos took during the investigation.
    "As soon as I realized it [the mislabeling], it was brought to attention," Thornton said.
    Thornton said outlet three was sent to the defense's expert, but labeled as another outlet.
    Tuten recognized that their expert did see outlet three, but stated that the expert did not have all the facts, and his opinion could have been altered if he knew it was one of the important outlets.
    Thornton said outlet four was sent to the investigators with the insurance company per their request. Thornton said he called the investigators to confirm they had outlet four in their possession, but the investigator told him he could not be sure it was indeed outlet four.
    Thornton maintained that outlet four was sent to the investigator, so it must be outlet four that is in his possession.
    The other outlets-one, two and five remained in question. Thornton said outlet one is the missing outlet, but it is not pertinent to the case; outlets two was damaged too severely to be of much help; and outlet five was left in the home when it was returned to owners on Aug. 22.
    Thornton testified that the police and fire department provided 24-hour security at the home from Saturday to Tuesday. The scene was expected to be released to the family on that Wednesday, but an electrical engineer was found to look at the outlets.
    Thornton said the door was boarded up on Tuesday night to prevent entrance into the house. The electrical engineer came on Thursday to look at the outlets.
    During his testimony, Thornton was also questioned about the position of the smoke detector.
    Thornton said the smoke detector did not suffer the same heat and smoke damage as the other items hanging on the wall, and in his opinion, it was removed from the wall before the fire.
    During cross-examination, Thornton agreed that the smoke detector could have been knocked off the wall because there was some light smoke damage to the detector. However, during redirection from the prosecution, Thornton said it was more likely the debris under the detector was there because it was kicked instead of being just knocked off the wall.
    Testimony in the case continues today at 8:30 a.m.

    Also on Franklin County Times
    “OLD GLORY”
    Franklin Living
    “OLD GLORY”
    Jeff Johnson 
    July 2, 2025
    Most of my life I have heard the flag of the United States of America affectionately called “Old Glory.” In my imagination I associated that phrase wi...
    4 cities, towns have contested mayoral elections
    Main, News, Russellville
    4 cities, towns have contested mayoral elections
    ELECTION
    Alyssa Sutherland For the FCT 
    July 2, 2025
    RUSSELLVILLE — Four of Franklin County’s cities or towns will have contested mayoral elections in the Aug. 26 municipal elections. The most hotly cont...
    {"epopulate_editorials_prism":"epopulate_editorials_prism"}
    Participants enjoy ‘Magic of Reading,’ the color of fruits and ballon animals
    Lifestyles, Russellville
    In the Community
    Participants enjoy ‘Magic of Reading,’ the color of fruits and ballon animals
    María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
    July 2, 2025
    RUSSELLVILLE Laughter, wonder and a touch of enchantment filled the Russellville Public Library as magician Russell Davis brought his show “The Magic ...
    {"epopulate_editorials_prism":"epopulate_editorials_prism"}
    FFA students bring home state convention honors
    Franklin County, News, Phil Campbell, ...
    FFA students bring home state convention honors
    María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
    July 2, 2025
    Red Bay and Phil Campbell FFA students, along with a Hackleburg member of the Franklin County Junior Cattlemen, earned state-level honors at Alabama’s...
    {"epopulate_editorials_prism":"epopulate_editorials_prism"}{"newsletter":"Newsletter"}
    Army’s future requires support, encouragement from community
    Columnists, Opinion
    Army’s future requires support, encouragement from community
    July 2, 2025
    “Thank you for your service,” are words I often hear while wearing my uniform in your community. I am grateful to hear those words, but what many peop...
    {"epopulate_editorials_prism":"epopulate_editorials_prism"}
    Allison tapped to lead Lady Bobcats softball
    High School Sports, Phil Campbell Bobcats, Sports
    Allison tapped to lead Lady Bobcats softball
    Bart Moss For the FCT 
    July 2, 2025
    PHIL CAMPBELL -- A familiar face will be leading the Phil Campbell High School Lady Bobcats softball program next season. Darby Allison, a 2007 gradua...
    {"epopulate_editorials_prism":"epopulate_editorials_prism"}
    6 local students accepted into FAME program
    Franklin County, Sports
    6 local students accepted into FAME program
    María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
    July 2, 2025
    Northwest Shoals Community College (NWSCC) has signed 6 Franklin County students to its 2025–26 Federation for Advanced Manufacturing Education (FAME)...
    {"epopulate_editorials_prism":"epopulate_editorials_prism"}
    Darby is denied parole
    News
    CRIME NEWS
    Darby is denied parole
    Bernie Delinski For the FCT 
    July 2, 2025
    MONTGOMERY -- A man serving a 10-year sentence on Franklin County assault convictions was denied parole on June 25, according to records from the Alab...
    {"epopulate_editorials_prism":"epopulate_editorials_prism"}

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    ❮ ❯
    Latest Local News
    4 cities, towns have contested mayoral elections
    4 cities, towns have contested mayoral elections
    RUSSELLVILLE — Four of Franklin County’s cities or towns will have contested mayoral elections in the Aug. 26 municipal elections.The most hotly conte...
    July 2, 2025
    Red Bay Police can use electronic signatures
    RED BAY – Police can now use electronic signatures for their reports. City council members approved the policy after learning it was a requirement to ...
    July 2, 2025
    Participants enjoy ‘Magic of Reading,’ the color of fruits and ballon animals
    Participants enjoy ‘Magic of Reading,’ the color of fruits and ballon animals
    RUSSELLVILLE Laughter, wonder and a touch of enchantment filled the Russellville Public Library as magician Russell Davis brought his show “The Magic ...
    July 2, 2025
    Rain delays repair projects
    RED BAY – Persistent rainfall has delayed drainage and road repair projects in the city. “You can’t dig when it’s mud,” Mayor Charlene Fancher said re...
    July 2, 2025
    Jars of drugs lead to a local trafficking arrest
    RUSSELLVILLE — A Russellville man is facing multiple drug-related charges, including two counts of drug trafficking after law enforcement located and ...
    July 2, 2025

    More Local News

    Latest Stories
    Jars of drugs lead to a local trafficking arrest
    RUSSELLVILLE — A Russellville man is facing multiple drug-related charges, including two counts of drug trafficking after law enforcement located and ...
    July 2, 2025
    Rain delays repair projects
    RED BAY – Persistent rainfall has delayed drainage and road repair projects in the city. “You can’t dig when it’s mud,” Mayor Charlene Fancher said re...
    July 2, 2025
    Red Bay Police can use electronic signatures
    RED BAY – Police can now use electronic signatures for their reports. City council members approved the policy after learning it was a requirement to ...
    July 2, 2025
    Land Transactions
    May 30 • Tim Horton and Charles Moudy to Kimberly Shay Horton and Timothy Chad Horton, survivorship • Mario Cifuentes Tello to Edilsar Noe Edcobedo Ro...
    July 2, 2025
    Teenager struck by lighting
    RUSSELLVILLE -- A 19-year-old woman is recovering after being struck by lightning while talking on a cellphone Saturday. Emergency personnel responded...
    July 2, 2025
    Latest Sports
    Allison tapped to lead Lady Bobcats softball
    Allison tapped to lead Lady Bobcats softball
    PHIL CAMPBELL -- A familiar face will be leading the Phil Campbell High School Lady Bobcats softball program next season. Darby Allison, a 2007 gradua...
    July 2, 2025
    6 local students accepted into FAME program
    6 local students accepted into FAME program
    Northwest Shoals Community College (NWSCC) has signed 6 Franklin County students to its 2025–26 Federation for Advanced Manufacturing Education (FAME)...
    July 2, 2025
    Junior golfers hone skills through summer program
    Junior golfers hone skills through summer program
    RUSSELLVILLE -- A young generation of golfers teed off this summer at Twin Pines Country Club, thanks to a local effort to create opportunities for ch...
    July 2, 2025
    Belgreen’s Moore earns First Team All-State honors
    Belgreen’s Moore earns First Team All-State honors
    BELGREEN -- Jemma Moore has been named to the AHSAA First Team All-State for softball, becoming just the ninth player in school history to earn the di...
    June 18, 2025
    Maddox retires after 26 years of shaping young minds at RMS
    Maddox retires after 26 years of shaping young minds at RMS
    R U S S E L L V I L L E -- Teaching for Diane Maddox has never been just about grammar rules or reading comprehension, but rather about connection, cr...
    June 18, 2025

    More Sports Stories

    x

    Sections

    • Home
    • News
    • Sports
    • Opinion
    • Lifestyles
    • Obits
    • Special Sections
    • Sponsored Content
      • Home
      • News
      • Sports
      • Opinion
      • Lifestyles
      • Obits
      • Special Sections
      • Sponsored Content

    Services

    • About Us
    • Subscribe
    • Advertise With Us
    • Policies
    • Terms of use
    • Submit a news tip
    • Submit a photo
    • Birth announcement
    • Birthday announcement
    • Engagement announcement
    • Wedding announcement
    • Submit a Classified Ad
    • Letter to the Editor
    • Sign Up For Our Free Newsletter
      • About Us
      • Subscribe
      • Advertise With Us
      • Policies
      • Terms of use
      • Submit a news tip
      • Submit a photo
      • Birth announcement
      • Birthday announcement
      • Engagement announcement
      • Wedding announcement
      • Submit a Classified Ad
      • Letter to the Editor
      • Sign Up For Our Free Newsletter

    Follow Us

    Copyright

    © , Franklin County Times