• 41°
franklin county times

A message for Jane Austen fans

By By Suzanne Monk / managing editor
June 27, 2004
I'm one of those women who has read "Pride and Prejudice" a dozen times in leather-bound illustrated editions and cat-chewed paperbacks.
I always hold my breath during Mr. Darcy's first, unsuccessful, proposal of marriage to Elizabeth Bennett certain that this time he will say the right thing or she will see past his formidable demeanor. It's agony to read the next hundred pages, waiting for Darcy to unbend enough for Elizabeth to realize she's misjudged him.
But, of course, the idea that the two might never come together is what creates the book's dramatic tension. Because it could so easily happen.
Most of the time, in my experience, it does.
Long before I fell for Mr. Darcy, I had discovered you can't do a thing with those kind of men: reserved, intelligent, private, undemonstrative and on a mission. Unknown and unknowable, they don't explain themselves to anyone on any subject, and they have a small circle of acquaintance with which they are perfectly content. It doesn't help that I have some of those same qualities.
Little wonder "Pride and Prejudice" is on my top five list.
If that seems strange for a known head-case like me, the other four are more predictably obscure: "Riddley Walker" by Russell Hoban, "A Time of Changes" by Robert Silverberg, "A Clockwork Orange" (or anything else) by Anthony Burgess and "Families: A Memoir and a Celebration" by Wyatt Cooper of, incidentally, Quitman, Miss.
Intentions and
interpretations
Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth Bennett are the story's only three-dimensional characters; for the most part, the rest are deliberate stereotypes, variously vicious, insipid or obsequious.
I'm sure Jane Austen would be surprised to learn that "Pride and Prejudice" has been handed down into the modern era as a full-blown romance owing mostly to the release in 1940 of a movie version starring Laurence Olivier and Greer Garson.
But, despite its intentions, the love story at the center is compelling and fans wanted sequels. Lots have been written. Up until last week, I had avoided them.
Eating the apple …
Grazing at Books-A-Gazillion, I ran across a disastrously irresistible new title, "Mr. Darcy takes a Wife," by Linda Berdoll.
This book imitates the formal, wordy prose of Jane Austen, with lots of commas and grace notes, but without approaching its elegance and restraint.
That's not really the worst of it.
The controlled comedic style of Austen's novel gives way in Berdoll's sequel to frowzy melodrama and all the convoluted language can't disguise the fact that Berdoll's Darcy and Elizabeth have 20th century sensibilities.
How can I put this delicately? Unless your contemplation of the Darcys' married life runs to the strategic placement of bedroom mirrors and the leaving on of one's riding boots, you're going to be disappointed.
It is what it is, I guess, but it's not a true-to-genre sequel to "Pride and Prejudice."
If you're a Jane Austen fan, don't watch while a first-time novelist of only moderate gifts peeps through Mr. Darcy's keyhole he would hate that.
Don't read this book.
I'm sorry I did.
Suzanne Monk is managing editor of The Meridian Star. Call her at 693-1551, ext. 3229, or e-mail smonk@themeridianstar.com.

Franklin County

PROGRESS 2024: Veteran Spotlight – Mousey Brown

News

Russellville First Baptist Church receives historical marker

Franklin County

PROGRESS 2024: Meeting a higher standard – Russellville High School JROTC

News

RCS BOE announces new superintendent  

News

Miss Dream Girl Pageant names winners

Franklin County

First Metro Bank hosts FAME Girls’ Ranch donation drive

News

PCHS holds annual Shelby Grissom Memorial Fashion Show

Franklin County

PROGRESS 2024: VFW Post 5184 – ‘No One Does More For Veterans’

Features

Supporting students’ futures

Features

Red Bay Garden Club discusses amaryllis planting

Franklin County

UA announces local students for fall 2023 President’s, Dean’s, graduation lists

News

School news

Franklin County

PROGRESS 2024: Veteran Spotlight – Troy Oliver

Franklin County

Appropriations bill passes, allots more than $3 million for new Russellville library/multipurpose center 

Franklin County

Franklin County Cattlemen’s Association names Cattleman of the Year 

Franklin County

Franklin County votes: Unofficial March 5 primary election results 

Franklin County

Funding for new Russellville library, multipurpose community center expected this week

Features

Faces of Franklin County: BTCPA

News

GFWC Russellville Book Lovers Club sponsors downtown art crawl

Franklin County

PROGRESS 2024: Veteran Spotlight – Cody Bragwell

Franklin County

42nd annual Miss RHS pageant names winners 

News

Miss RHS pageant takes place Friday

Franklin County

Political announcement: David Hester speaks about run for reelection as county commissioner

Franklin County

BTCPA auditions for final production of season take place March 3-4 

x