• 63°
franklin county times

Quasi-court, quasi-effective

By By Suzanne Monk / managing editor
July 28, 2002
The last time I wrote about Rita Jack's appeal to the Civil Service Commission, I remarked that you have to be a lawyer or hire one to make your way efficiently through the procedural maze of a hearing.
After part two of that hearing on Thursday night, I'm convinced that an appeal hearing's quasi-legal format and stopwatch mentality don't just make the whole thing more complicated than it needs to be. They actually obstruct the truth.
Each side, Jack and the city of Meridian, had one hour to present their case. Five hours into the hearing, I'm not sure I heard any witness complete a sentence amid repeated objections by attorneys for both sides.
Background
Jack was fired by Police Chief Benny DuBose amid allegations that she and a civilian employee, Vivian Groves, stole money and checks from the police station's front desk. The thefts occurred between February and May of 2001.
Groves admitted her guilt, but said Jack was her partner in the embezzlement scheme. Both were suspended and, ultimately, fired.
Jack was never arrested and denies the charges. District Attorney Bilbo Mitchell presented the case against Jack to a Lauderdale County grand jury in November, but the panel declined to indict her.
Groves was not prosecuted.
Jack appealed her termination to the Meridian Civil Service Commission. A hearing into the matter began on May 2; part two happened Thursday.
Court procedure
Appeal hearings before the CSC are conducted a lot like civil trials in Lauderdale County Circuit Court. Attorneys for each side present their witnesses and ask them questions during "direct examination."
The other side's attorney then cross-examines the witness. After that, the first lawyer comes back with more questions in his "re-direct."
In a courtroom, there are rules enforced by the judge about what you can ask witnesses and what questions they can answer. Why? Because the jury is not allowed to hear everything.
For example, say a defendant is on trial for sale of cocaine. The police found 20 pounds of it in a closet in his apartment, but they didn't have a search warrant. The search was illegal and the jury can't hear anything about the 20 pounds of cocaine. The judge will prevent that information from coming out during questioning.
The idea is to make sure that jurors don't hear any unfairly prejudicial testimony.
Square peg, round hole
The same rules apply in a hearing before the Civil Service Commission, but they are a bad fit because there are fundamental differences between trials and CSC hearings:
1. The five-member Civil Service Commission is both judge and jury;
2. Commissioners are privy to all discussions and sidebars between the CSC chairman, the CSC attorney and attorneys for the disputing sides; and
3. Commissioners, unlike jurors, get to ask their own questions.
If rules about testimony are designed to control what jurors get to hear, they seem a little out-of-place in a hearing where the jury in this case the Civil Service Commission is going to hear it all anyway.
And, there is a problem with the idea that commissioners can only hear the amount of truth that can be told on time remaining on a stopwatch. Especially if most of the time is spent discussing objections and fragmenting the narrative.
A more informal procedure would work better. Something without lawyers. Something more like letting the CSC call everyone in one at a time and ask the questions they think are important.
But, I'll bet it's against the rules.
The CSC's decision in Jack's appeal is expected within two weeks.
Two of my favorite guys
On an unrelated subject, two of my favorite community writers are included in this edition of The Meridian Star Bobby Rushing and McRae Limerick. Both are prolific contributors to the profile edition published each February.
Both are older gentlemen with a keen eye for detail.
Bobby's piece about family reunions is on the front page. It is contemplative, lyrical, kind, evocative. Like all good writing, its visual imagery tranports me to a different place. Bobby also has a rare gift for choking me up.
McRae's letter to the editor is on page A9. You probably remember him for his Profile story about training to be an airplane engine mechanic during World War IIj because he couldn't join the military.
Who but McRae Limerick could disagree in such a gentlemanly fashion? Criticize a person, while thanking them? It's an almost lost art in this day and age, they have seminars for it.
McRae is also an archivist, and his grasp of history is admirable, as is clear from his letter.
Make sure you check them out.

Franklin County

PROGRESS 2024: Veteran Spotlight – Mousey Brown

News

Russellville First Baptist Church receives historical marker

Franklin County

PROGRESS 2024: Meeting a higher standard – Russellville High School JROTC

News

RCS BOE announces new superintendent  

News

Miss Dream Girl Pageant names winners

Franklin County

First Metro Bank hosts FAME Girls’ Ranch donation drive

News

PCHS holds annual Shelby Grissom Memorial Fashion Show

Franklin County

PROGRESS 2024: VFW Post 5184 – ‘No One Does More For Veterans’

Features

Supporting students’ futures

Features

Red Bay Garden Club discusses amaryllis planting

Franklin County

UA announces local students for fall 2023 President’s, Dean’s, graduation lists

News

School news

Franklin County

PROGRESS 2024: Veteran Spotlight – Troy Oliver

Franklin County

Appropriations bill passes, allots more than $3 million for new Russellville library/multipurpose center 

Franklin County

Franklin County Cattlemen’s Association names Cattleman of the Year 

Franklin County

Franklin County votes: Unofficial March 5 primary election results 

Franklin County

Funding for new Russellville library, multipurpose community center expected this week

Features

Faces of Franklin County: BTCPA

News

GFWC Russellville Book Lovers Club sponsors downtown art crawl

Franklin County

PROGRESS 2024: Veteran Spotlight – Cody Bragwell

Franklin County

42nd annual Miss RHS pageant names winners 

News

Miss RHS pageant takes place Friday

Franklin County

Political announcement: David Hester speaks about run for reelection as county commissioner

Franklin County

BTCPA auditions for final production of season take place March 3-4 

x