Archives
 By  Staff Reports Published 
4:52 am Friday, June 28, 2002

Cutright airs Civil Service test grievances

By By Suzanne Monk / managing editor
June 28, 2002
Capt. Theresa Cutright of the Meridian Police Department got her chance Thursday to tell the Civil Service Commission what she thought was wrong with a test administered to candidates for the position of assistant police chief.
Eleven officers took the test on April 17. Three received passing grades Capt. Keith McCary, Capt. Betty Evans and Lt. Al Brown.
Cutright did not pass, and her concerns about the examination fell into two broad categories: 1) that some of the questions were out-of-date or did not relate to the assistant chief position; and 2) that "points" were added to the raw scores in an improper manner.
Adding points
Cutright's primary area of concern seemed to be how many points the members of the examining board added to the raw scores because the truth is, nobody really passed the test.
A score of 70 was required for a passing grade. Once the raw scores were tabulated, the highest score was 68. In this situation, the examining board is authorized to add a uniform number of points to each score in order to raise some of the applicants above the passing mark.
The question is how many points?
If you add enough points, everyone can pass. The idea is to add points in such a way that the most qualified test-takers in the group are raised into passing territory  without discriminating against other people with close, but lower, scores.
With the group that took the assistant chief's test, points were added, raising three applicants into the passing range. Chief Benny DuBose said he had considered a number of points that raised six scores into passing range, but rejected it.
Cutright questioned the method by which the examining board determined how many "added points" there would be. She also said there should be some degree of uniformity over time in the number of points added to Civil Service Commission exams.
DuBose said the added points did not discriminate against any particular officer and that test-takers were identified only by number at that point.
Other issues
Cutright said she recognized the test as one she had taken more than 10 years ago. She cited one question, in particular, that she said exemplified her concern that the test did not address current law enforcement situations.
It asked test-takers to choose among four options to complete the (paraphrased) sentence: "At the turn of the century, the reason for the change in prevailing police conduct was …"
Cutright said such questions are not appropriate in a work environment so influenced by technology, court rulings and procedural changes.
Attorney Lee Thaggard, representing the city of Meridian, said her criticism of one question out of the approximately 130 that were asked was insufficient to cast serious doubt on the test's validity.
Other discussion at the hearing centered around whether Cutright had filed her appeal in a timely fashion and DuBose's removal of 37 questions from the test before it was given.
WHAT'S NEXT?
The Meridian Civil Service Commission hopes to issue a ruling within 10 days in the case of Capt. Theresa Cutright. Its decision will be released into the public record only after the concerned parties have been notified by mail, and no assistant police chief will be named before then.

Also on Franklin County Times
Thorpe to play at Blue Mountain Christian
High School Sports, News, Russellville, ...
Brannon King For the FCT 
July 16, 2025
RUSSELLVILLE – Brennon Thorpe made his plans official to attend Blue Mountain Christian University and play baseball for the Toppers during a recent s...
Russellville High Class of 1967 gathers, reminisces
Columnists, News, Opinion, ...
HERE AND NOW
July 16, 2025
You can’t really go back to the good old days of high school, but you can pay them a visit now and then. That’s exactly what the RHS Class of 1967 has...
Former Cypress Lakes official to lead Guntersville State Park
Lifestyles, News
Bernie Delinski For the FCT 
July 16, 2025
GUNTERSVILLE — Heath Puckett had an Auburn University degree and golf course superintendent certification in his pocket when he arrived at Cypress Lak...
European travel builds bonds across cultures
Lifestyles, News, Russellville, ...
María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
July 16, 2025
RUSSELLVILLE -- A group of Franklin County travelers spent nine days this summer walking through catacombs, exploring castles and standing in places w...
Little Free Library welcomes readers in East Franklin
Lifestyles, News, Phil Campbell
María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
July 16, 2025
PHIL CAMPBELL — Eleven-year-old Aiden Hall is an avid reader, but he doesn’t just want to read books. He also wants to share them, and the way he deci...
King becomes elementary curriculum director
Lifestyles, Russellville
María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
July 16, 2025
RUSSELVILLE — Molly King says every child can learn, though not necessarily in the same way or on the same day — a belief she plans to carry into her ...
New Junior Leaders begin their training
Franklin County, News
María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
July 16, 2025
FRANKLIN COUNTY — Forty-two high school students from across Franklin County are beginning 10 months of hands-on leadership training and community ser...
Fire destroys 2-story garage, guest suite
Main, News, Russellville, ...
Kevin Taylor For the FCT 
July 16, 2025
R U S S E L LV I L L E – Jason Gist leaned against the wall of his home with a look of disgust while dozens of firefighters worked to extinguish a fir...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Stories
July 4, 2025Augusto Simon Diaz, 42, of Russellville, passed away July 4. Visitation and funeral were held at Spry Memorial Chapel on July 12 from 2pm ...
July 16, 2025
July 8, 2025Jamie Kerby Cummings, 41, of Russellville, passed away on July 8. Visitation took place July 13, at Spry Memorial Chapel from 1 pm to 3pm....
July 16, 2025
July 11,2025Julie “JuJu” Welch Black, 63, of Russellville, passed away on July 11.Graveside service was held at 1pm on July 13, at Belgreen Cemetery w...
July 16, 2025
July 9, 2025Scott Noel Benford, age 58, of Muscle Shoals, passed away on July 9. Visitation was held at Pinkard Funeral Home in Russellville on July 1...
July 16, 2025