• Subscribe
    • Franklin Living Magazine
    • Services
      • About Us
      • Subscribe
      • Policies
      • Terms of use
      • Submit a news tip
      • Submit a photo
      • Birth announcement
      • Birthday announcement
      • Engagement announcement
      • Wedding announcement
      • Submit a Classified Ad
      • Letter to the Editor
    • Classifieds
    • E-editions
    • Public Notices
      • Public Notices
      • Alabama Public Notices
    • Subscribe
    • Franklin Living Magazine
    • Services
      • About Us
      • Subscribe
      • Policies
      • Terms of use
      • Submit a news tip
      • Submit a photo
      • Birth announcement
      • Birthday announcement
      • Engagement announcement
      • Wedding announcement
      • Submit a Classified Ad
      • Letter to the Editor
    • Classifieds
    • E-editions
    • Public Notices
      • Public Notices
      • Alabama Public Notices

Franklin County Times
  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Opinion
  • Lifestyles
  • Obituaries
  • Records
  • Subscribe
  • Services
  • About Us
  • Subscribe
  • Policies
  • Terms of use
  • Submit a news tip
  • Submit a photo
  • Birth Announcement
  • Birthday announcement
  • Engagement announcement
  • Wedding announcement
  • Submit a Classified Ad
  • Letters to the Editor
  • Classifieds
  • Public Notices
    Franklin County Times
      • Site logo
      • Home
      • News
        • Russellville
        • Red Bay
        • Phil Campbell
        • Franklin County
        • Photo Galleries
        • Sponsored Content
      • Sports
        • Belgreen Bulldogs
        • Phil Campbell Bobcats
        • Red Bay Tigers
        • Russellville Golden Tigers
        • Tharptown Wildcats
        • Vina Red Devils
        • College Sports
        • Sports Columnists
      • Opinion
        • Letters to the Editor
        • Columnists
        • Editorials
      • Lifestyles
        • Birthdays
        • Births
        • Couples
        • Food
        • Features
      • Obituaries
      • Records
        • Sheriff’s Report
        • Marriages
        • Land Transactions
        • Police Reports
      • Special Sections
      • Site logo
      • Home
      • News
        • Russellville
        • Red Bay
        • Phil Campbell
        • Franklin County
        • Photo Galleries
        • Sponsored Content
      • Sports
        • Belgreen Bulldogs
        • Phil Campbell Bobcats
        • Red Bay Tigers
        • Russellville Golden Tigers
        • Tharptown Wildcats
        • Vina Red Devils
        • College Sports
        • Sports Columnists
      • Opinion
        • Letters to the Editor
        • Columnists
        • Editorials
      • Lifestyles
        • Birthdays
        • Births
        • Couples
        • Food
        • Features
      • Obituaries
      • Records
        • Sheriff’s Report
        • Marriages
        • Land Transactions
        • Police Reports
      • Special Sections
    Archives
     By  Staff Reports Published 
    5:08 am Wednesday, January 23, 2002

    Wednesday, Jan. 23, 2002

    By Staff
    Trial lawyer has say on proposed tort reform'
    To the editor:
    The escalating rhetoric in the "tort reform" battle poorly defines the sides. It appears, at first blush, to be business and doctors versus trial lawyers; at least, that is what the public is incorrectly being led to believe. The battle really pits insurance companies against Mississippi citizens. The alleged nationwide withdrawal of St. Paul Insurance Company from the medical malpractice insurance market is a perfect example. Every analyst agrees that St. Paul miscalculated its premium calculation (called "underwriting") and then lost money in the stock market, like many insurance companies did. St. Paul's threat to pull out of Mississippi has nothing to do with malpractice jury verdicts, where Mississippi still ranks below the national average. Further, if St. Paul is discontinuing its practice of writing medical malpractice coverage nationwide, it can't have anything to do with medical malpractice verdicts in Mississippi. Finally, we should all watch St. Paul closely and see whether they actually do discontinue writing this very profitable type of insurance business.
    Recent hearings before the insurance committees of the Mississippi legislature made the point very clear. Dozens of editorials driven by insurance propaganda did not change the facts. Dr. David Meredith of Jackson (also a lawyer) cited statistics from government documents and insurance company web sites documenting their profitability and testifying as to the conspiracy of misinformation. Consumer representatives also provided uncontested data proving that the number of doctors per capita in this state has continued to rise, even after identical accusations of mass retirement and departure were published in the mid-1980's during a similar economic downturn.
    In the mid-80's, many doctors were having difficulty finding affordable coverage. I do not doubt that a similar problem exists for them today. In the 80's, the insurance companies convinced the doctors that costs were being escalated by an explosion in litigation and claimed that frivolous lawsuits and out of control juries were forcing them to make insurance unaffordable or unavailable. Back then, they told state legislatures around the country that the only way to ease the crisis was to enact tort reform to make it more difficult for sick and injured consumers to sue and be compensated by wrongdoers. Sound familiar? The data presented to the insurance committees on Dec. 19 showed that states with compulsory caps on compensation do not provide insurance premium relief for doctors or anyone else. In fact, in California, where the greatest medical tort reform occurred, rates increased 37 percent at a time when national insurance rates increased less than 6 percent.
    Moreover, insurance commissioner George Dale and state medical association president Hugh Gamble both agreed that the proposed limits on compensation will not likely reduce insurance premiums. Medical Assurance Company of Mississippi, the leading insurer of doctors in this state, wins 90 percent of their trials and made $7 million in profit last year. This information can easily be ascertained by simply checking its Web site. If there is a crisis, then there can be no doubt that it is a self-inflicted phenomenon caused by the mismanaged underwriting practices of the industry itself.
    The nursing home industry has also jumped on the tort reform band wagon. A recent editorial from the Delta Democrat Times stated that in 1999 "the state had 17 companies who were writing policies for nursing homes. There are only three now, and, according to Gamble, they have no intention of renewing their policies " The nursing home industry is quietly trying to insulate themselves from accountability under the guise of tort reform as well. Meanwhile, the statistics sadly illustrate the pathetic level of care provided in Mississippi nursing homes. An October 2000 state-by-state comparison found a dramatic rise in facility deficiencies in our state since 1997. Over the last three years, there have been substantial increases in seven quality of care areas. Perhaps the most staggering figure is the fact that nearly 60 percent of the homes in our state were cited for violating sanitary standards. In 1999, Mississippi led the nation in accident violation with nearly 250 percent more violations than the national average. It would be unconscionable and a grave disservice to our elders to allow the industry the "reforms" it seeks.
    Is there any good news? Yes. The supervisor of the Mississippi Public Employees Health Insurance plan, Therese Hannah, provided some excellent news that did not get published in this or any other paper that I read. She testified that Mississippi had the lowest health insurance premiums in the country and Mississippi pays the lowest percentage of its budget for state employee health insurance. Here is one area where Mississippi is ranked first.
    After testifying at the recent hearings, I was asked by a member of the committee whether the Mississippi Trial Lawyers Association would support any "tort reform." I responded by telling him that is depends on how you define "tort reform." If tort reform means dismantling a judicial system which has worked better than any system on the planet for hundreds of years and continues to do so, then the answer would be no. On the other hand, if by tort reform you mean supporting anti-secrecy legislation which would prevent companies like Firestone and Ford from keeping secret wrongful death settlements then the answer is yes. If by tort reform you mean passing legislation that allows the families of patients in nursing homes to install cameras to monitor the treatment of their loved ones, the answer is yes. If by tort reform, you mean passing legislation which would require physicians to disclose to patients any disciplinary procedures, the answer is also yes.
    The next time someone asks if you are in favor of tort reform, be sure you know how they define it before you answer.
    David W. Baria
    Mississippi Trial Lawyers Association
    President-elect
    Jackson

    Also on Franklin County Times
    PHOTO GALLERY: Jam at Sloss Lake
    Franklin County, Galleries, Lifestyles
    PHOTO GALLERY: Jam at Sloss Lake
    Griffin Traylor 
    July 9, 2025
    Auditor says city’s financial health is very good
    Main, News, Russellville, ...
    Auditor says city’s financial health is very good
    María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
    July 9, 2025
    RUSSELLVILLE -- The city has received what its auditor called a “clean opinion” on its fiscal year 2024 audit, meaning no significant deficiencies or ...
    {"epopulate_editorials_prism":"epopulate_editorials_prism"}
    Place of Grace opens recovery home in Franklin County
    Franklin County, Main, News, ...
    Place of Grace opens recovery home in Franklin County
    María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
    July 9, 2025
    The Place of Grace has opened a new recovery home in Franklin County, offering women a structured, faith-based environment to continue their journey a...
    {"epopulate_editorials_prism":"epopulate_editorials_prism"}
    Hamilton: Title II funding freeze is a concern
    Main, News, Russellville, ...
    Hamilton: Title II funding freeze is a concern
    Alyssa Sutherland For the FCT 
    July 9, 2025
    R U S S E L L V I L L E – Franklin County Superintendent Greg Hamilton is concerned about the status of more than $6 billion in federal education gran...
    {"epopulate_editorials_prism":"epopulate_editorials_prism"}
    Fire Department receives new $2.2M platform truck
    Main, News, Russellville, ...
    Fire Department receives new $2.2M platform truck
    María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
    July 9, 2025
    RUSSELLVILLE Firefighters and city officials showed off the Fire Department’s new $2.2 million 100-foot platform fire truck in a safety demonstration ...
    {"epopulate_editorials_prism":"epopulate_editorials_prism"}
    Palmer certified for fourth term on Russellville Council
    News, Russellville, Z - News Main
    Palmer certified for fourth term on Russellville Council
    María Camp maria.camp@franklincountytimes.com 
    July 9, 2025
    RUSSELLVILLE – The city council approved a certificate of election stating Councilman David Palmer was the only candidate to qualify for Council Distr...
    {"epopulate_editorials_prism":"epopulate_editorials_prism"}
    Summer camps nurture faith, friendship and growth
    Columnists, Opinion
    HERE AND NOW
    Summer camps nurture faith, friendship and growth
    July 9, 2025
    Susie Hovater Malone Columnist During the summer many Franklin County youths enjoy attending summer camps, where they engage in hiking, swimming, spor...
    {"epopulate_editorials_prism":"epopulate_editorials_prism"}
    The prosperity we enjoy depends on Sea Lanes of Communication
    Columnists, Opinion
    The prosperity we enjoy depends on Sea Lanes of Communication
    July 9, 2025
    The Pax Americana, the period since World War II when there have been no major world wars, has led to the greatest period of freedom the world has eve...
    {"epopulate_editorials_prism":"epopulate_editorials_prism"}

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    ❮ ❯
    Latest Local News
    PHOTO GALLERY: Jam at Sloss Lake
    PHOTO GALLERY: Jam at Sloss Lake
    July 9, 2025
    Auditor says city’s financial health is very good
    Auditor says city’s financial health is very good
    RUSSELLVILLE -- The city has received what its auditor called a “clean opinion” on its fiscal year 2024 audit, meaning no significant deficiencies or ...
    July 9, 2025
    Place of Grace opens recovery home in Franklin County
    Place of Grace opens recovery home in Franklin County
    The Place of Grace has opened a new recovery home in Franklin County, offering women a structured, faith-based environment to continue their journey a...
    July 9, 2025
    Hamilton: Title II funding freeze is a concern
    Hamilton: Title II funding freeze is a concern
    R U S S E L L V I L L E – Franklin County Superintendent Greg Hamilton is concerned about the status of more than $6 billion in federal education gran...
    July 9, 2025
    Fire Department receives new $2.2M platform truck
    Fire Department receives new $2.2M platform truck
    RUSSELLVILLE Firefighters and city officials showed off the Fire Department’s new $2.2 million 100-foot platform fire truck in a safety demonstration ...
    July 9, 2025

    More Local News

    Latest Stories
    Municipal elections: Let your voice be heard on Aug. 26
    Qualifying for municipal races across the state, including Franklin County, closed on June 24 leaving several contested races leading up to the Aug. 2...
    July 9, 2025
    TVA surcharge to raise August bills for customers
    RUSSELLVILLE Electricity customers should expect higher bills in August as TVA passes along a surcharge driven by high summer demand and a recent outa...
    July 9, 2025
    Hutcheson participates in CCHS program
    Hutcheson participates in CCHS program
    PHIL CAMPBELL — Rising Phil Campbell High School senior Hudson Hutcheson spent most of his summer at the University of Alabama. An aspiring dentist, h...
    July 9, 2025
    Being struck by lightning was ‘shocking experience’
    Being struck by lightning was ‘shocking experience’
    RUSSELLVILLE — Lisa Henderson was lying on her bed, scrolling through social media sites on her phone and enjoying a cozy, rainy Sunday afternoon with...
    July 9, 2025
    Jeffreys named new head football coach at Red Bay
    Jeffreys named new head football coach at Red Bay
    RED BAY -- Tyler Jeffreys has been named the new head coach at Red Bay High School. Jeffreys is stepping in to replace Heath Childers, who recently re...
    July 9, 2025
    Latest Sports
    Jeffreys named new head football coach at Red Bay
    Jeffreys named new head football coach at Red Bay
    RED BAY -- Tyler Jeffreys has been named the new head coach at Red Bay High School. Jeffreys is stepping in to replace Heath Childers, who recently re...
    July 9, 2025
    Hamilton to play baseball at Blue Mountain College
    Hamilton to play baseball at Blue Mountain College
    RED BAY -- Red Bay High School’s Reed Hamilton has officially signed a scholarship to continue his education and baseball career at Blue Mountain Coll...
    July 9, 2025
    Allison tapped to lead Lady Bobcats softball
    Allison tapped to lead Lady Bobcats softball
    PHIL CAMPBELL -- A familiar face will be leading the Phil Campbell High School Lady Bobcats softball program next season. Darby Allison, a 2007 gradua...
    July 2, 2025
    6 local students accepted into FAME program
    6 local students accepted into FAME program
    Northwest Shoals Community College (NWSCC) has signed 6 Franklin County students to its 2025–26 Federation for Advanced Manufacturing Education (FAME)...
    July 2, 2025
    Junior golfers hone skills through summer program
    Junior golfers hone skills through summer program
    RUSSELLVILLE -- A young generation of golfers teed off this summer at Twin Pines Country Club, thanks to a local effort to create opportunities for ch...
    July 2, 2025

    More Sports Stories

    x

    Sections

    • Home
    • News
    • Sports
    • Opinion
    • Lifestyles
    • Obits
    • Special Sections
    • Sponsored Content
      • Home
      • News
      • Sports
      • Opinion
      • Lifestyles
      • Obits
      • Special Sections
      • Sponsored Content

    Services

    • About Us
    • Subscribe
    • Advertise With Us
    • Policies
    • Terms of use
    • Submit a news tip
    • Submit a photo
    • Birth announcement
    • Birthday announcement
    • Engagement announcement
    • Wedding announcement
    • Submit a Classified Ad
    • Letter to the Editor
    • Sign Up For Our Free Newsletter
      • About Us
      • Subscribe
      • Advertise With Us
      • Policies
      • Terms of use
      • Submit a news tip
      • Submit a photo
      • Birth announcement
      • Birthday announcement
      • Engagement announcement
      • Wedding announcement
      • Submit a Classified Ad
      • Letter to the Editor
      • Sign Up For Our Free Newsletter

    Follow Us

    Copyright

    © , Franklin County Times